THAILAND AT YOUR RHYTHMIslands · Nature · Individual travel

Comparison of reviews of excursions to Phi Phi from Phuket: what tourists choose

Comparison criteria: what tourists look at in reviews

Every third tourist in Phuket chooses an excursion to Phi Phi, but 40% of reviews contain complaints about overcrowding of the beaches and organization. In order not to join the ranks of the disappointed, you need to understand in advance by what parameters experienced travelers evaluate a trip. An analysis of hundreds of reviews of Phi Phi excursions from Phuket shows that all the complaints and praise revolve around five key points.

The first and most important criterion is boat type. It determines how much time you will spend on the road, how comfortable you will be during the move and how many hours you will have left on the islands. Second - quality and format of lunch: buffet in a restaurant or packed lunch on the beach. Third - number of stops and time at each. Fourth - transfer organization (is the guide late, is there any traffic jams). Fifth - ratio of price and service received. It is these parameters that tourists mention in reviews most often, and it is on them that you should rely when choosing.

Option 1: Speedboat excursion

A speedboat is the most popular option among independent tourists who want to do as much as possible in one day. Reviews of the excursion to Phi Phi on a speedboat are full of emotions: from delight to seasickness.

What is praised:

  • “The journey took only 45 minutes, not 2 hours like on a big boat” — speed is really the main plus. You have time to visit Maya Bay, Phi Phi Ley Bay, the observation deck and Monkey Bay Beach.
  • “Lunch in an air-conditioned restaurant is a salvation from the heat.” — the speedboat program almost always includes a hot lunch at a stationary restaurant on Phi Phi Don.
  • “The guide was funny, we managed to take a lot of photos” - rich program and energetic pace.

What they criticize:

  • “The motion was unreal, I held on to the handrails all the way.” — the speedboat travels at high speed, and on the waves it shakes violently. People with vestibular problems suffer.
  • “There were 30 of us in the boat, sitting shoulder to shoulder.” — crowding is a common complaint. There is almost no legroom; luggage is stacked at the feet.
  • “They only gave us 40 minutes at Maya Beach - we didn’t even have time to swim.” — due to the busy schedule, the time at each stop is strictly limited.

A typical portrait of a tourist who leaves a positive review on a speedboat: young, without children, ready for an active pace. Negative - a family with a child or an elderly person who was seasick, and those who were expecting a relaxing beach holiday.

Option 2: Big boat excursion

A large boat is the choice of those who value comfort above speed. Reviews from tourists about excursions to Phi Phi on a big boat are noticeably calmer in tone, but contain their own pitfalls.

What is praised:

  • “The boat is huge, there is shade, a toilet, you can walk around without it shaking.” — stability and space are the main trump cards. You can sit on the bow, sunbathe on the upper deck, and not be afraid of motion sickness.
  • “Very comfortable with a child - he slept on the bench all the way” — families with children choose a big boat precisely for the opportunity to accommodate a child.
  • “The guide didn’t push us, we swam calmly with masks on” - more relaxed pace, more time for snorkeling.

What they criticize:

  • “We swam for 2 hours one way - it’s tiring” — a long road eats up half the day. You spend less time on the islands than on the road.
  • "Lunch - plastic container with rice and chicken on the beach" — instead of a restaurant, you are given a lunch box. Flies, heat and lack of tables are a common sight.
  • “The engine is so noisy that after 15 minutes my head starts to hurt.” — old boats with diesel engines are noisy and smell of diesel fuel.

A big boat is a compromise between comfort and experience. It is ideal for those who are afraid of motion sickness, traveling with children or simply want to avoid the stress of a high-speed race. But be prepared for a modest lunch and a long journey.

Comparison table: speedboat vs big boat by reviews

Criterion Speedboat Big boat
Travel time (one way) 45–60 minutes 1.5–2 hours
Comfort when rolling Most often they scold - strong shaking Most often praised - stability
Lunch Hot buffet in a restaurant Lunch box on the beach or on a boat
Time on the islands More stops, but less time on each Fewer stops, but more time on each
Suitable for children Mostly not recommended More often recommended
Overall rating in reviews 4 out of 5 (but many polar ratings) 3.5 out of 5 (even, no delight)
The main takeaway from the table: speedboat gets higher marks for experience and food, but falls short for comfort. Big boat is a safe choice with no surprises, but with a less flashy program.

Conclusion: which excursion to Phi Phi to choose based on reviews

An analysis of reviews of excursions to Phi Phi from Phuket leads to a simple rule of thumb: choose not a tour operator, but a type of boat. It is he who determines 80% of your impressions.

Speedboat is your option if:

  • You are young, active and ready for a busy schedule.
  • You have no problems with the vestibular system.
  • You want to try a hot lunch in a restaurant rather than eat on the sand.
  • Ready to put up with cramped spaces to save time.

Big boat is your option if:

  • You are traveling with children or elderly relatives.
  • Are you afraid of motion sickness or have already experienced seasickness?
  • Do you want to swim and dive calmly, and not run on a schedule.
  • We are ready to sacrifice the quality of lunch for the sake of comfort on the road.

Remember: reviews are a subjective experience. What one tourist would call a “terrible shaking”, another would consider a “fun adventure”. The main thing is to honestly answer the question: “What is more important to me - speed and intensity or comfort and peace of mind?” When you clearly understand your priority, choice ceases to be a lottery. Comparing Phi Phi excursions based on reviews is not about finding the ideal, but about finding an option that matches your expectations.